What Happens When Brilliance Meets Madness?
History has seen some of the greatest minds struggle with their own genius, often walking a fine line between brilliance and insanity. Two of the most fascinating mathematicians of the 20th century—Vashishtha Narayan Singh from India and John Forbes Nash Jr. from the U.S.—lived eerily similar yet vastly different lives.
Both were prodigies. Both made groundbreaking contributions to mathematics. And both battled schizophrenia, which cast a long shadow over their genius. But while Nash’s story became world-famous thanks to the movie A Beautiful Mind, Singh’s tale remains relatively unknown outside India.
So, let’s take a brutally honest, journey through their extraordinary lives, from their meteoric rise to their struggles and redemption—or lack thereof.
The 1940s: The Birth of Two Prodigies
-
June 13, 1928 – John Forbes Nash Jr. hails from Bluefield, West Virginia, USA.
-
April 2, 1942 – Vashishtha Narayan Singh was born in Basantpur, Bihar, India.
Both came from humble backgrounds. Nash’s father was an electrical engineer, while Singh’s family lived in a rural village. Despite their differences in upbringing, one thing was common—they were both exceptionally gifted in mathematics from an early age.
Nash was known for solving complex problems in his notebooks instead of paying attention in class, while Singh shocked his teachers at school with his ability to solve advanced equations far beyond his grade level. The world had no idea what was coming.
The 1950s: The Rise of a Genius
-
1950: At just 22 years old, Nash joined Princeton University for his Ph.D. His doctoral thesis, Non-Cooperative Games, revolutionized game theory and later won him a Nobel Prize in Economics.
-
1952: Meanwhile, in India, Singh was gaining a reputation as a child prodigy. His teachers at Patna Science College were astonished by his abilities.
A famous story goes that Singh once corrected the work of his professors! Imagine being so good at math that your teachers start learning from you. India had a living genius, yet the system didn't know what to do with him.
The 1960s: Breaking Boundaries in Mathematics
-
1961: Nash, at the peak of his career, began showing signs of schizophrenia—hallucinations, erratic behavior, and paranoia.
-
1961: Singh completed his M.Sc. in Mathematics from Patna University, where he continued to impress everyone.
-
1963: Singh was offered admission to University of California, Berkeley, where he worked on Reproducing Kernels and Operators under John L. Kelley.
Despite being on different continents, their stories ran in parallel—both pushing the limits of human understanding in mathematics.
Singh’s talent was so remarkable that NASA took notice. Yes, NASA! He was reportedly involved in their Apollo space missions, using his mathematical genius to help with calculations. Yet, India barely paid attention.
Meanwhile, Nash was spiraling into schizophrenia, believing that he was being contacted by aliens and chased by spies. His world was turning upside down.
The 1970s: Love, Marriage, and Tragedy
-
1966: Nash married Alicia Larde, a physics student who deeply loved him despite his mental health struggles.
-
1971: Singh returned to India after earning his Ph.D. in the U.S. He married Vandana Rani, but their relationship was doomed from the start.
Unlike Nash’s wife, who stood by him through his illness, Singh’s wife left him just a few years after their marriage, unable to cope with his schizophrenia.
This was the turning point in Singh’s life. His marriage fell apart, his mental health deteriorated, and he became increasingly isolated.
Meanwhile, Nash was hospitalized multiple times in the U.S. and was given painful shock therapy as treatment.
Both men—once celebrated—were now fighting inner demons. But one had a safety net. The other was free-falling into oblivion.
The 1980s-1990s: The Darkest Years
For Nash, the 1980s were a time of slow recovery. He had spent decades in and out of hospitals, but by the late 1980s, he started regaining control of his mind.
For Singh, however, things only got worse. Unlike Nash, who had Alicia by his side, Singh had no support system. His family, institutions, and even the Indian government largely forgot about him.
For nearly two decades, Singh lived in obscurity, battling poverty and mental illness, often wandering the streets of Bihar.
The world had moved on.
The 2000s: Redemption for One, Tragedy for Another
In 1994: Nash was awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics for his groundbreaking contributions to game theory. He was finally celebrated again.
-
2011: Singh was rediscovered and honored in India, but by then, it was too late. His health had deteriorated.
-
2015: Nash and his wife Alicia tragically died in a car accident just when he had started to enjoy his second chance at life.
-
2019: Singh passed away in a hospital in Patna. Unlike Nash, who was given a hero’s farewell, Singh’s death barely made national headlines.
What Can We Learn from Their Stories?
Both Nash and Singh were geniuses. Both fought schizophrenia. But their fates were starkly different:
-
Nash had support—his wife, the academic community, and the world rallied around him.
-
Singh was abandoned—his marriage collapsed, he was ignored, and India failed to recognize him until it was too late.
Their stories teach us three crucial lessons:
-
Genius alone is not enough—support systems matter. Singh could have been India’s Nash, but the lack of support destroyed him.
-
Mental health should never be ignored—early intervention could have changed Singh’s life. Imagine if India had provided him with the resources and care he needed.
-
A nation must protect its heroes. The U.S. did it for Nash. India failed Singh. Even when he was found years later, it was more of a token recognition rather than the structured rehabilitation he needed.
One became an Nobel-Prize-winning legend, the other—a forgotten genius.
![]() |
| Image by jcomp on Freepik |
It is too late for Vashishtha Narayan Singh, but it is not too late for future minds like him. Will we do better? Or will we let another genius slip through the cracks of history?








